66 Comments
User's avatar
Jean Oppermann's avatar

Thank you for this poignant and thoughtful piece, Leah. I "lost" my best friend a year ago. She was so alive and then she wasn't. I wasn't prepared for the body blow her death caused. I had a very hard year.

At this age "losing" people, and other things, i.e. mobility, hearing, sight, energy, is the measure of our days.

Mortality has been on my mind a lot this year. What is the measure of a life? All the knowledge, experiences of things that can no longer be found in this world, and even wisdom, all wrapped up in a body that ages and fails and fades away. We are each like a time capsule of our life, a repository of the history of our time here on earth; so much inside us and then poof It's gone! - except the memories of what you left behind.

Not necessarily happy thoughts, but something to chew on as we continue to fill the last decades of our own private time capsule.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Impossible not to chew on it. The challenge is not to let it color everything gray. But anyone who doesn't think about mortality is a dope!

Expand full comment
Eve Meyer's avatar

A memory is in such good hands with you. Grateful for the sharing of this universal ache, the way you have burnished it.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Oh, let’s do coffee soon.

Expand full comment
Eve Meyer's avatar

Any Wednesday

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Got class until the end of May. After that!

Expand full comment
Frank Viviano's Tuscany's avatar

Painfully beautiful, intensely moving, and as always with your work, utterly eloquent in its consideration of the fundamental truths that define what it means to be human. I lost four very close friends this past year, my 77th. Haven't fully absorbed their absence yet. On the family scoreboard, I'm now the oldest surviving member on both the maternal and paternal sides of large Sicilian immigrant clans. That gives me pause (Gulp!) but far more it saddens me in the ways you so poignantly describe.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Me, too, Frank. I grew up in the family Mother Ship in Brooklyn, the house that was the center of all celebrations and all catastrophes. I am the only one living who grew up there. That's probably justified, because I was the youngest. But it leaves me feeling empty to know that I'm the only one who remembers that life there. xx

Expand full comment
Frank Viviano's Tuscany's avatar

Family memory seldom lasts more than three generations. It is extraordinarily fragile--especially among the descendants of immigrants.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Yes, and I am thinking about the suitcases crammed with family photos in our attic. I knew all my great-aunts and uncles. Naming them for my kids would be useless.

Expand full comment
Judith Green's avatar

Still here, dear Leah, with memories of hiding under the table at Seders, playing cards on the sunporch, the wooden blocks stored under a cabinet or the fridge in the downstairs kitchen, the baby grand in the living room, the miniature animals in your and M’s room, and my last time there for beloved Uncle’s funeral. ❤️

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Will reply in email. Xx

Expand full comment
Michael Bernard's avatar

My mother, a Holocaust survivor who will soon turn 96 in a few days, offers this pragmatic advice: you will lose friends and family. Make friends two and three generations younger than you. Start today. In a few years, those woven friendships will fill holes in the warming blanket. Not in the same way, but in a novel way. They will bring their own warmth; welcome it. They are the ones with whom to share the memory of the lost and missing friends and family.

Thank you, Leah, for your poignant reminder to keep the memory of those we cherish in the face of our loss of them.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Oh I have already started! Your mom’s advice was good

Expand full comment
Sandra Phillips's avatar

Always wonderfully sympathetic dear Leah, thank you again, Sandy

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Thanks, Sandy. So many of our pals!

Expand full comment
Summer Brenner's avatar

Diminished, yes! Almost 14 months have passed since the dearest of friends died. She meant the world to me. Her photo is by my bed. I find myself smiling at her, and still in disbelief that she's gone. So sorry for your tsunami of losses. However, as you poignantly remind us, they're here somewhere inside us. But also it's not the same. PS: This made me smile: "Her father bought her a corsage to wear on the plane when we took off from New York."

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Aw, was going to send you a photo but I seem to have elctronically misplaced it. Ignore following message.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Am sending you a photo by email or text.

Expand full comment
cbrees's avatar

ah, damn. i know those holes in the blanket won't go away any time soon, but i hope those of us who love you and are still here can keep you warm. big hugs and xox to you, dear leah

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

You are one of the warming elements, dearie. Meet for tea one day?

Expand full comment
cbrees's avatar

yes, please. soon!

Expand full comment
rosaliempakenham@aol.com's avatar

Kate was my big loss last month. I and many will miss her.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Heartbreaking . She was such a fierce warrior

Expand full comment
Sue Thornley's avatar

Yes, diminished is the right word. Memories no longer available for discussion and laughter, answers to questions I want to ask, no longer available. Yes, diminished.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Oh those questions, those conversations unexpressed. In a few cases (the first two I wrote about), I more or less got to say goodbye. With the others, it's just a raw edge.

Expand full comment
Bonnie Metzger's avatar

What we all face now as those before us faced. Age is a lonely hunter. I am so moved by such loss. Knit a warm blanket for yourself in their memories

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

I suppose the warmest blanket is the people we still have at our sides. Thanks for responding, Bonnie

Expand full comment
Bill Owens's avatar

At 85 I lots to do and so little time

Your comments rang true

Bill Owens

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Thanks so much, Bill. Take comfort in all you have done.

Expand full comment
Lary Schiller's avatar

Leah, Holding back tears with your wonderful post, reminding me of all the friends I have lost. Your writing is remarkable and I think you should collect all your posts in a book, publish it somehow, and have a book signing party with all the desserts like those amazing parties of olde.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Mousse! A reason to go on living

Expand full comment
Lary Schiller's avatar

That’s the reason we had to hire Alley Cat pest control. Oh, mousse, sorry.

Expand full comment
Lucy Gray's avatar

Thank you for this lovely eulogy. I find it impossible just to let go of people so I have my ways of grieving like I started cooking from NYT recipes because a dear friend used to love to do that for his wife and tell me about it with his characteristic aplomb. Then he died suddenly. But ten people in seven weeks! I can’t cook that much!

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Trying to come up for air now.

Expand full comment
Beth Devener's avatar

I’ll be celebrating my 72nd BD tomorrow. Hard to believe, the yrs are passing too quickly. Let’s make a point to enjoy every day! Happy Birthday🧡

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

We share that May 2 birthday!

Expand full comment
Beth Devener's avatar

Let’s make it a good one!! I’m going to see the herd of seals at Pier 39🤣Happy Day to you🎂🎉🥳

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Thank you! Say hi to everyone who barks

Expand full comment
Beth Devener's avatar

That’ll be about a thousand!!🦭🦭🦭🦭🦭🦭

Expand full comment
tlstrauss@aol.com's avatar

Such deep feeling, expressed with such vividness and light--you convey the reality of life, friendship, appreciation and loss in all the ways that it's both profound, and incomprehensible. You write from the human heart, and speak to us all.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Thanks so much, Terry. Xxx

Expand full comment
Pat Schultz Kilduff's avatar

I can't quite wrap my head around diminished associated with you. You are so present. There memories are clearly a blessing. One you have shared with us.

Expand full comment
Leah Garchik's avatar

Such a wonderful note. I loved our coffee last week. Xx

Expand full comment